Education

Transitional Kindergarten: The Ultimate Guide for Parents

Discover everything you need to know about Transitional Kindergarten. Help your child succeed—explore TK programs near you today!

As a teacher and a mother of three, I know how overwhelming it can be to navigate the world of early education. The journey of preparing your child for kindergarten is filled with questions, emotions, and a sense of urgency to ensure your child is ready for what’s to come. One option that has brought comfort and success to many families—my own included—is Transitional Kindergarten (TK).

When my youngest child was approaching the age for school, I found myself wondering whether she was truly ready for the full kindergarten experience. I wanted something that would ease her into the transition, something that would give her the time to grow and develop at her own pace. That’s when we discovered Transitional Kindergarten. It was the perfect fit, offering not just academic preparation but emotional and social growth too.

If you’re feeling the same way—unsure about whether your child is ready, or what to expect from the school year ahead—this guide is for you. In this article, I’ll share everything I’ve learned about TK, from its many benefits to how you can prepare your child for success. No parent should feel alone in this journey, and I’m here to help make the process a little easier. Let’s dive into how Transitional Kindergarten can give your child the foundation they need for a bright future.

1. What is Transitional Kindergarten and How Does It Work?

Definition and Explanation of Transitional Kindergarten (TK)

Transitional Kindergarten (TK) is a unique educational program designed for children who are close to turning five but may not yet be ready for the academic demands of traditional kindergarten. It serves as a bridge between preschool and kindergarten, providing an extra year of preparation. The goal is to give children a head start in school, both academically and socially, so that they can thrive once they enter kindergarten.

TK combines the benefits of early childhood education with a more structured environment, offering a curriculum that focuses on social-emotional skills, foundational math, and early literacy. It’s a gentle introduction to the school setting, where children can develop a love for learning in a supportive and nurturing environment. Think of it as a stepping stone that helps children transition smoothly into the world of formal schooling.

I recall the first time I walked into a TK classroom—immediately, I was struck by how warm and inviting it felt. The teachers took the time to nurture each child’s emotional needs while also introducing them to basic academic concepts. It’s a perfect mix of fun and learning, where young minds can explore new concepts at their own pace. TK isn’t just about teaching; it’s about preparing children to thrive as confident, curious learners.

Differences Between Transitional Kindergarten and Preschool

At first glance, Transitional Kindergarten and preschool might seem similar. Both programs focus on early childhood development, but there are some key differences that set them apart. Preschool is typically for younger children, usually ages 3 to 5, and has a more relaxed curriculum. It focuses on play-based learning, social skills, and introducing basic academic concepts. Preschool can vary in structure, with some programs being more focused on creative play and others offering some academic activities.

On the other hand, TK is a more formalized program that prepares children for kindergarten. While it still incorporates play-based learning, it also includes a curriculum that aligns more closely with the kindergarten standards. TK is designed to ensure that children are fully prepared for the academic demands of kindergarten, helping them to develop skills in reading, writing, and basic math. One important distinction is that children in TK are typically older than those in preschool, usually around 4 to 5 years old.

In my experience, children who attend TK often experience a smoother transition to kindergarten because they have had that extra year to grow academically and emotionally. It’s a great option for children who might be on the younger side of the kindergarten age cutoff or those who could benefit from more time to develop before starting formal school.

How TK Fits into the Early Childhood Education System

Transitional Kindergarten plays an essential role in the broader landscape of early childhood education. It acts as a bridge between preschool and kindergarten, stepping in where a child’s needs might not be fully met by either program alone. It’s for the children who are not quite ready for kindergarten’s formal academic environment but would benefit from more structure than what preschool offers.

The early years of a child’s education are incredibly important. Research consistently shows that the first few years of school set the foundation for future learning. TK helps provide that foundation by focusing on both academic skills and emotional readiness. It’s not just about learning the ABCs; it’s about helping children develop emotional regulation, social skills, and a sense of confidence—all critical for success in school.

I’ve seen firsthand how TK helps children who might struggle in a traditional preschool setting because of their age or developmental pace. The added year allows children to catch up on skills they might not have developed yet and builds the confidence they need to succeed in kindergarten.

Overview of TK Programs Offered in Different States or Districts

While Transitional Kindergarten is a relatively new concept in some areas, it has become a vital part of the educational system in many states and districts across the U.S. The availability and structure of TK programs can vary significantly depending on where you live. In some states, TK is publicly funded and available to all children who turn five by a certain cutoff date. In others, it may be offered as part of a broader early childhood education initiative, with eligibility requirements based on age or developmental needs.

For example, California was one of the pioneers in offering TK programs as part of the state’s education system. In California, TK is available to children who turn five between September and December, providing them with an additional year of early education before kindergarten. Other states, like Texas and New York, have varying TK offerings, often depending on local district policies and funding availability.

Before enrolling your child in a TK program, it’s important to check with your local school district to learn about the specific criteria for enrollment, as well as the curriculum and support services offered. Some districts may offer TK as a free public program, while others may have private or charter options. It’s worth researching to determine what’s best for your child’s developmental needs.

When I was looking into TK options in my area, I was surprised by the differences from one district to another. Some offered full-day programs, while others had half-day schedules. There was also variation in how the curriculum was taught, with some districts emphasizing academic learning, while others focused more on emotional and social growth.

2. Benefits of Transitional Kindergarten for Your Child

Enhanced Social and Emotional Development

One of the standout benefits of Transitional Kindergarten (TK) is its emphasis on social and emotional development. The early years are crucial for building these foundational skills, and TK provides a nurturing environment that helps children grow emotionally. By engaging in activities that foster communication, cooperation, and empathy, children develop the confidence to interact with peers, express their feelings, and navigate social situations.

In TK, teachers guide children through learning how to share, wait their turn, and express frustrations appropriately. For example, a child might initially struggle with waiting for their turn during group activities, but through gentle guidance, they learn self-regulation and patience. Over time, these small lessons build a strong emotional foundation that helps them interact with others in a positive, healthy way.

I remember a student in my TK class who had a hard time making eye contact with others. Over the course of the year, we worked on group games and sharing time, and I saw a remarkable shift. By the end of the year, not only was he more confident in speaking up, but he was also eager to participate and communicate with others. TK offers a space where children develop socially and emotionally, setting them up for success in kindergarten and beyond.

Improved School Readiness and Academic Skills

Transitional Kindergarten is specifically designed to help children build the academic foundation they need for kindergarten. It’s not just about teaching the ABCs; it’s about creating a solid base in literacy, math, and cognitive skills that will prepare children for the more structured learning environment of kindergarten. Through play-based learning, songs, and hands-on activities, children are introduced to early reading, writing, and math concepts in a fun and engaging way.

For example, children in TK may learn to recognize letters and their sounds through interactive games, building a foundation for reading. They might also practice counting through play, such as counting objects during a group activity or using math games to introduce simple addition and subtraction concepts. These early skills set the stage for academic success and ensure that children feel comfortable when they enter kindergarten.

When I first started teaching, I noticed that students who had attended TK were much more confident with basic academic skills, such as letter recognition and early math. This gave them a head start in kindergarten and allowed them to focus on more advanced topics. TK programs tailor activities to suit each child’s developmental level, so they are ready for the next step in their educational journey.

Easier Transition to Kindergarten

Starting kindergarten can be a big adjustment, but kids who attend TK often have an easier time transitioning. They’re already familiar with the school routine, such as following a schedule, working in groups, and managing their belongings. Because TK programs are designed to mirror kindergarten in many ways, children who attend TK are less likely to feel overwhelmed when they step into a full-day kindergarten program.

For instance, TK students often practice sitting at desks, following instructions, and engaging in classroom activities, which are skills they’ll need in kindergarten. Children also get used to the idea of being in a more structured learning environment, which helps them build the self-discipline needed to thrive once they move into kindergarten.

I saw this firsthand in my class when one of my former TK students entered kindergarten. She was excited, confident, and ready for the challenge. While many of her peers struggled to adjust to the longer school day and new routines, she embraced the change with ease. The familiarity with school routines and expectations made her transition smooth, and she was able to focus on her academics right away.

Individualized Attention and Support in TK Programs

One of the great things about Transitional Kindergarten is the individualized attention children receive. Because TK class sizes are often smaller than traditional kindergarten classes, teachers are able to provide more personalized instruction. This means that if a child is struggling with a particular concept, the teacher can work with them one-on-one or in small groups to ensure they fully understand the material.

For example, if a child is having trouble with letter recognition, the teacher can take extra time to work with that child individually, using activities that cater to that specific need. Similarly, if a child excels in a certain area, the teacher can offer enrichment activities that challenge them and keep them engaged.

I recall a student who was very shy and initially struggled to keep up with the rest of the class. Thanks to the individualized support and attention he received, he gradually gained confidence and improved in his academic skills. The smaller class size allowed him to receive the help he needed without feeling embarrassed or overwhelmed. This personalized support is one of the key reasons why TK can be such a successful educational experience for young learners.

3. How to Know if Your Child is Ready for Transitional Kindergarten

Key Developmental Milestones for TK Readiness (Cognitive, Social, Emotional)

When thinking about whether your child is ready for Transitional Kindergarten (TK), it’s important to consider a few key developmental milestones. These milestones cover cognitive, social, and emotional readiness, ensuring that your child will thrive in a structured learning environment.

Cognitive Skills: At this age, children should be able to recognize basic shapes, numbers, and letters. They may also begin to grasp simple concepts like sorting objects or identifying patterns. For example, a child might be able to count to ten or recognize a few letters of the alphabet. Children in TK are often ready to expand their understanding of basic math and literacy, so it’s important for them to be able to follow simple instructions and engage in activities that involve problem-solving.

Social Skills: TK is a social environment, so it’s essential for children to be able to interact with peers. A child who is ready for TK can share toys, wait their turn, and communicate their needs effectively. They’re also beginning to understand the concept of empathy, such as recognizing when another child feels sad or happy and responding appropriately. Social interactions like playing games together or having conversations during snack time are key parts of the TK experience.

Emotional Skills: Children entering TK should be developing emotional regulation skills. This includes knowing how to handle frustration or disappointment in a positive way. For instance, a child who can voice their feelings instead of acting out will be better equipped to handle the challenges of a more structured day. Emotional readiness also includes a sense of independence, such as being able to separate from a parent without becoming overly distressed.

When I taught TK, I often saw children arrive with different strengths in these areas. Some were naturally more emotionally mature, while others took a little longer to adjust. It’s important to remember that developmental milestones are guidelines, and every child develops at their own pace.

Signs That Your Child Might Benefit from TK

Not all children are ready for the transition to kindergarten, and TK can be a wonderful bridge for those who need a little extra time to adjust. Here are some signs that your child might benefit from TK:

Struggles with Social Interactions: If your child is still working on making friends, sharing, or waiting their turn, TK can provide the structured social environment that encourages these skills. TK programs often focus on building these interactions, helping children grow more comfortable in group settings.

Difficulty Separating from Parents: Some children may still have trouble with the separation anxiety that often accompanies entering kindergarten. If your child experiences significant distress when you drop them off at school, TK can offer a gradual transition into the school environment, helping them adjust to longer school days and being away from home.

Needs Extra Time to Develop Academic Skills: If your child is not yet familiar with basic concepts like letters, numbers, or shapes, but shows an eagerness to learn, TK can help prepare them for kindergarten. TK offers a gentle introduction to these concepts in a way that builds confidence and curiosity.

I remember one of my students, who was academically bright but struggled with social cues. TK helped him work on these skills before kindergarten, and by the time he entered kindergarten, he was not only ready academically but emotionally as well.

Discussing Readiness with Your Child’s Preschool or Daycare Provider

When deciding whether TK is the right choice for your child, it’s a great idea to have an open conversation with your child’s preschool or daycare provider. They have firsthand insight into your child’s development and can offer valuable perspective on whether a TK program would benefit them.

Ask About Social and Emotional Development: A preschool teacher can give you an idea of how your child is interacting with peers. Do they engage in group activities? Are they able to follow simple instructions and manage their emotions?

Academic Readiness: Teachers can also provide feedback on whether your child is showing signs of readiness for more structured academic learning. Are they interested in learning letters and numbers? Do they seem ready for activities that involve more focused attention?

Growth Opportunities: If there are areas where your child could benefit from extra time to develop, their teacher might suggest TK. This gives you a chance to address any concerns you might have while giving your child the support they need.

By discussing your child’s readiness with their preschool or daycare provider, you can make a more informed decision about whether TK is the right fit. One of my favorite conversations with parents has always been about their child’s growth. Together, we looked at their child’s developmental progress and made plans for the next steps.

Age Requirements and Eligibility for TK Programs

Each state or school district may have different age requirements and eligibility criteria for Transitional Kindergarten programs. It’s important to understand these guidelines to ensure your child qualifies.

In many places, children must turn five years old by a certain date, usually between September 1st and December 31st, to enroll in TK. However, some areas may have slightly different cutoff dates, so it’s always a good idea to check with your local school district. If your child is too young for kindergarten but will turn five before the cutoff date, they may be eligible for TK.

Some districts have additional eligibility requirements, such as assessing whether a child is developmentally ready for TK. This may involve looking at academic, social, and emotional milestones, as discussed earlier. In some cases, parents can request an assessment if they believe their child would benefit from TK even if they are not yet five.

When my own children were about to enter school, I remember feeling a bit uncertain about whether they were ready. I called the local school district to inquire about their specific eligibility rules, and they were more than happy to help me navigate the process. It’s always worth checking the details with your district to ensure your child gets the support they need.

4. What to Expect in a Transitional Kindergarten Classroom

Typical Daily Activities and Curriculum in a TK Setting

In a Transitional Kindergarten (TK) setting, the day is designed to balance structured learning and play. Think of it as a combination of fun and foundational education. A typical day includes activities that help children build important skills while keeping them engaged and curious.

Morning Circle Time: The day often starts with circle time. This is where children gather on the carpet to greet each other, talk about the weather, and discuss the day’s activities. It’s a wonderful opportunity to practice listening skills, follow directions, and learn new concepts. For example, a teacher might introduce the letter of the day, and the children will sing songs or participate in activities related to that letter.

Learning Centers and Stations: After circle time, children often rotate through various learning centers. These centers might include an arts and crafts station, a reading corner, or a math area with hands-on activities. These stations provide opportunities for children to explore subjects at their own pace. It’s not just about reading or numbers; it’s about creativity, exploration, and social interaction too. In one session, a child might be building a tower with blocks while practicing counting, and in another, they might be engaged in a story where they’re learning about empathy.

Snack and Playtime: After a little work, it’s time for snack and free play. This is when children can recharge by enjoying a snack and then having some unstructured time to play with their peers. This time helps them practice social skills like sharing, taking turns, and problem-solving. I remember how my students would excitedly negotiate who would get the red block or who would be the leader in their pretend play games.

Storytime and Group Activities: The day wraps up with storytime, where children sit together to listen to a story. The teacher may ask questions throughout the story to promote comprehension skills and encourage participation. Afterward, children often engage in a group activity that relates to the story, like drawing pictures or acting out what they heard.

How TK Programs Focus on Academic and Social Skills

Transitional Kindergarten programs are designed to strike a balance between academics and social development. Both are equally important for setting children up for success in kindergarten and beyond.

Fostering Academic Growth: In TK, children are introduced to a variety of foundational academic concepts in a way that’s both fun and interactive. Teachers focus on building literacy skills, such as letter recognition, phonics, and early writing. For example, children might match pictures with letters or trace letters in sand. Numbers and shapes are also introduced in creative ways, like through songs or games. This hands-on approach helps children understand key concepts while keeping them engaged.

Building Social Skills: In addition to academics, TK places a strong emphasis on social skills. Children learn how to share, take turns, and communicate their needs. Activities like group games or collaborative art projects help children practice these skills. For instance, during a group activity, one child might be the “leader,” while others learn to follow instructions. This is also the time when children learn how to express their emotions in a healthy way, like asking for help when they’re frustrated or talking about their feelings.

A well-rounded TK program weaves both of these aspects into the daily routine. I’ve seen children grow tremendously in their ability to interact with others while also developing the academic skills they need for the next stage of their education.

Teacher-Student Ratio and Classroom Environment

The teacher-student ratio in a TK program is a crucial factor in providing quality education. A lower ratio allows for more individualized attention and a more nurturing environment. Typically, the ratio in a TK setting is around 1 teacher to 12 or 15 students, though this can vary depending on the state or district.

Smaller Class Sizes for More Focus: The smaller class sizes in TK programs allow teachers to give more focused attention to each child. For example, in a smaller group, a teacher can work one-on-one with a student who needs extra help identifying letters or numbers, or they can provide more guidance during playtime to help children navigate social challenges. This personal attention helps children feel seen, heard, and supported.

A Safe and Inviting Classroom Environment: The classroom environment in a TK program is designed to be warm, inviting, and safe. It’s a space where children can express themselves and feel comfortable. The classroom is often filled with colorful materials, books, and engaging displays that reflect the learning happening every day. The furniture is child-sized, and everything is accessible to foster independence. For example, children may have their own cubby where they can store their belongings, promoting a sense of responsibility and ownership.

I recall how in my classroom, the students loved the “calm corner” where they could go to relax if they felt overwhelmed. A well-designed classroom creates an atmosphere where children feel secure enough to explore, learn, and grow.

How TK Supports Children’s Individual Learning Styles and Needs

Every child is unique, and a great TK program recognizes and supports individual learning styles. Teachers understand that children learn in different ways—some are visual learners, others are auditory or kinesthetic, and some might need a bit more time to grasp certain concepts. TK programs provide opportunities for all learning styles to thrive.

Differentiated Instruction: Teachers in TK programs are trained to use differentiated instruction, which means they adjust their teaching strategies to meet the diverse needs of their students. For example, a child who learns best by moving might be given extra time to engage in physical activities that reinforce academic concepts. A child who loves to draw might be encouraged to express their understanding through art.

Flexible Grouping and Support: In TK, children may work in small groups with peers who have similar learning needs. For example, if a group of children needs extra help with counting, the teacher might lead a small group lesson while the others continue working on an independent activity. This flexibility ensures that no child gets left behind and that everyone receives the support they need.

Social-Emotional Support: In addition to academic support, TK programs also focus on emotional development, which is vital for children’s overall growth. Teachers recognize when a child is feeling overwhelmed or anxious and can offer tailored support, whether it’s through a calming activity or extra encouragement. For example, a child who struggles with separation anxiety might be given a special job or a “buddy” to help them feel more secure.

By supporting each child’s unique needs, TK programs provide a nurturing environment where children can thrive both academically and emotionally.

5. How to Prepare Your Child for a Successful Transition to Kindergarten

Tips for Parents to Ease the Transition to TK and Kindergarten

The transition to Transitional Kindergarten (TK) or kindergarten can be both exciting and nerve-wracking for both parents and children. As a mother and teacher, I know firsthand how important it is to make this change as smooth as possible. Here are some tips to help you guide your child through this transition.

Start a Routine Early: One of the biggest adjustments for children is getting used to a school schedule. Weeks before the first day, start waking up at the same time and having breakfast, followed by a simple activity like reading a story or practicing basic skills. This helps children adjust to a routine and know what to expect.

Talk About School Excitedly: Kids are incredibly perceptive, and if you approach the idea of school with excitement, they are likely to mirror that energy. Talk about all the fun things they will do—making new friends, learning new songs, and playing in a big classroom. I remember telling my own kids about how wonderful their teachers were, and how they would have a special place to hang their backpack!

Visit the School Together: Many schools offer orientation sessions or meet-and-greet events. If not, consider visiting the school before the first day. Walk around, see the classrooms, and introduce your child to the teachers. This familiarity can make the first day feel less daunting. It’s a great way to ease any anxiety.

Stay Positive and Be Patient: Transitions take time. There will be good days and tough days, and that’s completely normal. Stay patient with your child and yourself. The process may take a while, but with support, your child will adjust.

Discussing the Upcoming Change with Your Child

Talking about the upcoming transition is essential in helping your child feel prepared for TK or kindergarten. It’s natural for them to feel uncertain about what’s to come, and your words can make a world of difference.

Keep the Conversation Age-Appropriate: Young children often have a limited understanding of what school is like. Keep the conversation simple and positive. Explain that school is a place where they will learn new things, make new friends, and have fun. You can even compare it to something they already love, like a favorite game or activity.

Validate Their Feelings: It’s completely normal for children to feel nervous or excited about starting school. If your child expresses concerns, listen carefully. Let them know that it’s okay to feel unsure, but assure them that school is a safe and fun place. Share your own experiences to show them that you understand.

Use Books and Stories: A great way to ease anxiety is through stories. There are many children’s books about starting school that help children understand what to expect. One book I always recommend is The Kissing Hand by Audrey Penn, which helps children feel more comfortable with separation.

Role-Play School: Sometimes, children need to experience something before they feel ready for it. Try role-playing school at home. Set up a “classroom” and take turns playing teacher and student. This can help children visualize themselves in the classroom and reduce any fear of the unknown.

Creating a Supportive Home Environment for Learning

A supportive home environment plays a crucial role in preparing your child for TK and beyond. It’s not just about having a designated study space; it’s about fostering a mindset that values learning and growth.

Create a Learning Space: While your child might not have homework in TK, it’s still important to provide a space where they can focus on learning. Set up a cozy corner with books, art supplies, and puzzles. This can become their “learning zone,” where they feel encouraged to explore new ideas.

Encourage Curiosity: Children are naturally curious, and it’s important to nurture that curiosity. Encourage them to ask questions, explore the outdoors, and engage in activities that develop their problem-solving skills. For example, you could explore nature by going on a “treasure hunt” for leaves, rocks, or insects, which helps build cognitive and observational skills.

Limit Distractions: It’s easy to get caught up in the hustle and bustle of daily life, but creating moments of focus is important. Limit screen time, especially during learning activities. Children often absorb information better when they’re actively engaged, rather than passively watching TV. Instead, set up family activities that promote learning, like cooking or building a puzzle together.

Praise Efforts, Not Just Results: A supportive home environment is one where children feel encouraged to try new things without the fear of failure. Praise their efforts, not just the outcomes. For example, if they’re learning to write their name, celebrate their effort even if the letters aren’t perfect yet. This builds resilience and confidence.

Encouraging Socialization and Independence Before the School Year Starts

Before school begins, it’s important to give your child opportunities to socialize and practice independence. These skills are essential for a smooth transition and can set the stage for a successful year.

Arrange Playdates: Playing with peers is one of the best ways for children to develop social skills. Arrange playdates with children who will be in the same class or neighborhood. This allows your child to practice sharing, taking turns, and resolving conflicts in a low-pressure environment.

Encourage Independent Tasks: Independence is an important skill for young children, and it’s never too early to start. Encourage your child to take on small tasks independently, such as putting on their own shoes, tidying up their toys, or choosing their own clothes. Praise their independence, and gradually increase the complexity of these tasks as they grow more confident.

Teach Problem-Solving Skills: Help your child develop basic problem-solving skills by giving them opportunities to work through challenges. For example, if they can’t find a toy, ask them questions like, “Where did you last play with it?” or “What can we do to solve this problem?” This teaches them to think critically and solve problems on their own.

Foster Emotional Independence: Helping your child manage their emotions before school starts can make a big difference in their ability to cope with change. Discuss emotions with them openly and teach them simple strategies like deep breathing or counting to ten when they feel upset. These tools will help them feel more in control when they encounter challenges at school.

By encouraging these skills before TK starts, you’re setting your child up for success in both social situations and classroom interactions.

Conclusion

Transitional Kindergarten (TK) plays a crucial role in setting the foundation for your child’s educational journey. It provides a bridge between preschool and kindergarten, offering an enriching experience that fosters academic, social, and emotional growth. TK prepares children not just for school, but for life, by developing key skills that will help them succeed in the classroom and beyond.

As a parent, it’s important to explore local TK programs and begin the enrollment process when your child is ready. These programs are an invaluable opportunity to ensure your child is equipped with the tools they need for a smooth transition into formal education. Trust that TK isn’t just a step toward kindergarten—it’s a pathway to a successful and confident start in school.


FAQs

Q1: What’s the difference between Transitional Kindergarten and preschool?
Answer: TK focuses on preparing children for kindergarten with a more structured curriculum, while preschool is generally less formal.

Q2: When is the best time to enroll my child in a Transitional Kindergarten program?
Answer: The best time is when your child is developmentally ready, typically around 4 years old, depending on your local district’s age cutoff.

Q3: Are there any specific eligibility requirements for Transitional Kindergarten?
Answer: Eligibility varies by state or district, but most programs are available to children who turn 5 years old after the cutoff date for kindergarten.

Q4: How can I find a Transitional Kindergarten program near me?
Answer: Visit your local school district’s website or contact your child’s preschool for information about nearby TK programs and enrollment procedures.

National Association for the Education of Young Children (NAEYC)
The NAEYC is a reputable organization dedicated to promoting high-quality early childhood education. It provides valuable resources, research, and insights that can complement your article on Transitional Kindergarten.

Leave a Comment